Ever look up those verses of scripture you see on signs at sporting events? We see John 3:16 prominently displayed on signs behind goalposts. We see Philippians 4:13 on Tim Tebow’s eye-black. Other athletes have tattoos of their favorite scriptures. As Christians, we love seeing those types of conspicuous references. Those passages warm our hearts and give us hope, as they should, because we have a relationship the living God. However, in an atheist’s mindset, those verses don’t paint an accurate picture of the God they envision. They believe that in order to paint an accurate portrait of God, people should paint passages like Isaiah 45:7, Judges 21:21 or Numbers 31:7 on signs instead.

Mark defines the act of cherry-picking as finding a passage of popular, feel-good scripture to provide a broad answer to the tough question(s) he asks or to counter the accusations he makes. Too often, Christians just refer to those popular verses and then attempt to avoid a hard issue. For example, if an atheist professes that God is cruel and unloving and a Christian simply replies with John 3:16, it will not fully suffice. Christians have to tell the entire story behind John 3:16 to validate the answer. To even have a chance to make a case with an atheist, a Christian must have a broad knowledge and wide range of scriptural references that pin-point the hard-hitting issue at hand.

Mark writes, “You can cherry pick out any verses you like in defense. Yet these people have used the same book to persecute women, people of other races, people of other religions, etc.” It is true that even today many ruthless Christians stand on street corners and condemn people and lifestyles. Sadly, some churches have even been classified as hate groups and not unjustly. Atheists do not discount those types of actions as non-Christian. Conversely, they believe those acts are truly representative of what our God condones. Atheists isolate passages anywhere in the Bible as long as they back up their attacks on God. Through study and analysis, though, Christians should be able to find that they do not need to cherry-pick scripture. The lessons and teachings of the Bible withstand even the toughest scrutiny.

The Bible covers thousands of years and many cultures. That, in itself, makes it hard for anyone to comprehend and no one can completely comprehend it. It’s meant to be understood in layers, meaning that it takes at least a couple of readings to begin to comprehend it and each reading reveals more meaning. It is written by human hands but dictated by God. He didn’t make it easy and Christians have made it harder. We have avoided hard parts and leaned on the feel-good verses.

It’s been said that the acronym for the Bible is: Basic Instructions Before Leaving Earth. As a man, I can attest to not always understanding instruction manuals. If I pick up the manual for putting together my weed trimmer and just start reading it, I doubt I will understand it without being hands-on with the task. Often times, I have to read the instructions more than once to understand and those are just a few simple steps. The Bible contains thousands of pages of different forms of instructions and isn’t intended to be grasped simply in excerpts. So, is Mark right? Do we just pick out the verses of love and forgiveness and gloss over the rest because we think the happy verses get us saved?

More to come…


About The Christian Culture

Understanding the past, present and future cultural applications of the Bible. Using that understanding to better live out Mattew 28:19-20.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to CHERRY PICKING

  1. Travis Mundy says:

    No, Matt is wrong and he lacks wisdom and discernment. Scripture is foolishness to an unbeliever. (1 Cor 2:14). Matts is powerless against the living God. I’ve never been one to give up on people but evil people will never be won over by words over the web. Instead, we are probably better off to spend our time encouraging believers and willing people. Satans biggest victories come when he distracts followers with crafty speech, and takes us off our game. Just love Matt and pray for him to be released from captivity. It’s simple, easy, and effective. I don’t believe for a second that God is ashamed of one single pen stroke. All scripture is useful for teaching and rebuking (2 Timothy 3:16). In fact, Matt is described most accurately in 2 Timothy 3.

    • The Christian Culture says:

      He simply does not have a relationship with Jesus. Our relationships with The Lord are our proof of God. That’s the entire basis of the Christian faith. It’s also easy to make your argument when you only cherry-pick biblical passages you want, which atheists who hate God do. They don’t read the Bible in its entirety to connect the dots. I’ve read a lot online about atheists as a result of our conversation and he has helped me better understand the Bible itself and why Satan hates it. The Devil is crafty and can bend the word of God many different ways. It’s the way he caused the very first sin with Eve and it’s the way he continues to do it today. It’s the responsibility of every Christian to KNOW the Bible. It is so easily defensed if we learn it and have confidence in it.

  2. Travis Mundy says:

    Rob, that’s exactly right brother. Infant Christians, even as stellar as they might be, should never get in an online argument with an unbeliever. Folks like Matt will almost never be won over by proof-texting, cherry-picking, or any other eisegesis. In fact, scripture is “foolishness” (1 Cor 2:14) to a guy like Matt, so it probably makes no sense to quote scripture to him or any other Atheist unless we know exactly what we are talking about. God’s word says, “to be quick to listen and slow to speak.” My main point is that we shouldn’t be afraid to use scripture b/c it’s powerful, and it wards off Satan’s futile attempts. If I quote scripture to a believer, they should go read it in it’s entirety so they can gain wisdom and understanding. Bottom-line, words have a very marginal chance of winning someone to Jesus over the internet. Words can move people to search for the Truth, but our actions will always speak louder when it comes to winning hearts and minds.

  3. The Christian Culture says:

    Our conversation may not have yielded any immediate fruit but we never know how the seed will be planted. Maybe it won’t. I entered the conversation simply to understand what an atheist believes. Not only did I gain a lot of valuable insight listening to his side but he also guided me through one of the greatest Bible studies I’ve ever been in, although that was not his intention. I perhaps learned more through him than did in any other “small group” study I’ve every been in.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s